This film is a perfect example of what happens when the greats work past their prime. It’s just a sad waste. In this one instance, I will not rejoice, because— like Peter Griffin assessing The Godfather — “I did not care for” The Irishman. Simply do what they have been doing for decades, have someone else play the actors in their younger. Nothing new in the typical mob story here. Stephanie Kurtzuba as Irene Sheeran Obviously, in this case, the models weren’t CG … but you get the point. If you are entertained by the movie. I'm trying to find something good about this movie but can't. As it is, what Scorsese gives us with The Irishman is an unglamorous return to mob movie territory, where the men’s half-CG faces are now fraying at the edges, skin-walking in unnatural ways. Filled with pointless dialogue and it is clearly only getting great reviews because the big name actors are there. Skip it, ir rent it later. Its the 21st Century and here Deniro romanticizes life as a loudmouth, racist, bully CGI old man who uses Catholicism as a predictable prop. Martin Scorsese did a marvelous job selling this to Netflix, because no one else would play it. I love football, but I don't want to see a 63 year old Joe Montana take the field. TERRIBLY long.. and usually, tedious. Al Pacino as James Riddle "Jimmy" Hoffa. Even the scenes of violence and suspense are deliberately dispassionate, as if to confess that these things should not be spectacles. Welcome to the uncanny valley. Make it stop. So let’s go with the idea of Leo-led flashbacks, for posterity. There were several scenes involving dialogue between two characters in which they argued. I apologize to Scorsese because you have an immense talent, but I suspect you already know it doesn't work. I really don't know how this is a must-see film. I held out a long time before watching it, wife wanted to see it badly and insisted on seeing it all in one sitting, so took a while to find the time. Wait to see it for free. Simply put, this movie is not for me. I was going to give 0 but ended up giving 1 because Al Pacino still looks like he is at least barely alive. That sounds sarcastic, but I genuinely wonder if the lack of home video game consoles throughout my life has left me ill-prepared to stomach the intrusive visual effects in The Irishman. Check box if your review contains spoilers, A huge (and lengthy) swing and a miss from Scorsese, De Niro, and Netflix. But this is not good. There are moments of sudden, gory violence, all with no value. Way too long and not all that interesting. I've loved Scorsese movies for decades. I wanted love this, but honestly it was hard to watch Deniro & Pesci personally act out the stories from their past and try to pull off looking,sounding and moving somewhat youthful. The Irishman is an epic saga of organized crime in post-war America told through the eyes of World War II veteran Frank Sheeran (Robert De Niro), a hustler and hitman who worked alongside some of the most notorious figures of the 20th Century. Pervasive and extremely foul language gets in the way of the story. Goodfellas is my all time favorite movie and I admire the team that put together the Irishman. Joe Pesci and Robert De Niro in The Irishman | Netflix. Very Bland very. Very Bland very boring very predictable. Web design by Pro Blog Design. And it's even surprisingly, frequently touching and funny. “The Irishman” presents mob life as a far more solemnly unromantic and toll-taking experience. Scorsese retourne à ses amours, à savoir la grande saga mafieuse dont il a le secret ou plutôt dont il avait le secret dans le temps, jadis... il a convié à cette réunion nostalgique les comparses d'antan comme Joe Pesci et Robert de Niro. Hopefully he gets back on track with that new Decaprio feature he is prepping to shoot. A film of masterly hushed precision, it digs deep into … It goes without saying that his cinematic legacy is secure. It's like an olg people's home from hollywood. It has no social importance or, more seriously, redemption. The so-called talent phoned in their performances; these guys are all ready for retirement and it shows. This movie is unbelievably long and dull. What began as a kidnap/ransom business eventually turned into running security for bootlegging on behalf of the Lansky-Purple Gang-Bronfman empire. Bad camera work. Goodfellas is my all time favorite movie and I admire the team that put together the Irishman. Apologies in advance to the hard-working people at Industrial Light & Magic and all the rest of the cast and crew of The Irishman. Movies like this have littered the film landscape for 38 years since 1972’s The Godfather (which did the same thing but so much better, mainly because the genre was new). After the first 30 or 40 F bombs and MFers it gets a bit tiring. The plot was meandering and directionless, the writing stale and regurgitated. As a military veteran, I was disgraced by his behavior and Scorsese shouldn't make another movie and Deniro should play roles to his left heeding political space allow him to. The Irishman is a convoluted mess, no where near Scorsese's best work and nothing he hasn't done before. Overrated and boring Movie. Initially, I would rate it a 5 but on reflection, this was a complete waste of my time. One thing that's common among all Scorsese movies is the dialogue. Their performances are solid, but just needed a better story. The movie is full of cliche lines that are meant to seem deep, but fall very short. Time for some tough love. Unless you're predisposed to unconditionally and indiscriminately love just about anything by Team Scorcese/DeNiro/Pacino, you'll be disappointed in The Irishman. This is Scorsese at his most predictable, overlong, and self-repetitive. It would have rescued this movie from expensive CG fakery and filled in a big missing face hole in the reunion pic from Scorsese’s filmography. Initially, I would rate it a 5 but on reflection, this was a complete waste of my time. Affiliate links used when available. Really a movie for critics. I've thought about this movie a lot. The 1st act is good, but then Al Pacino chews the scenery and the film gets boring and bogged down in a political drama. Absolutely awful. Story line is of interest although not factual but....the....movie....just....drags... on and on. He does an impersonation of himself as a young man but he is moving like old man. But the acting was uninspired, particularly from Pesci and Pacino who always seemed to be. When I say that, it’s with full acknowledgment that I’m a little blogging ant whose accomplishments in life pale in comparison to Scorsese’s. This movie is a one time watch for me. As a work of entertainment, it has enough drama and humor to keep viewers invested. There are no women, no blacks, no other ethnicities My review: The Irishman is part of a dead genre that no one cares about anymore. The Irishman uses this very mortal limitation to its artistic advantage. They are neither cold nor hot. And story tellers. I felt like it added this strange, puffy plasticity to their faces, and I would catch their faces rippling or shimmering at odd times—as if they were watery shapeshifters who hadn’t yet perfected their human masquerade. Film Review: The good, the bad, and 'The Irishman' By David Palmer Thursday Nov 7, 2019 at 3:58 AM. No way does this movie deserve a 94 weighted score. Martin Scorsese's exciting, epic-length new crime film, The Irishman, isn’t Goodfellas Light or Goodfellas 2, it is more an inverse Goodfellas. In the end, just a DEPRESSING excersize in Mafia bleakness; you don't care about ANY of these people. It's as if Scorcese is trying to give a Morality Lesson after all the "glamourous" Mob films of the past. The film's mammoth runtime doesn't help in this regard; it's a slow, thoughtful, and reflective work, which isn't necessarily as … Pesci was understated and magnificent, while DeNiro and Pacino seemed miscast and cartoonish. Retro is cool as retro. There were several scenes involving dialogue between two characters in which they argued about minor inconsequential details, repeating those details back to one another through numerous camera changes, and the viewer is left wondering, "Did I just sit through 30 seconds of another meaningless conversation about whether the mob ‘really means it this time'"? But the acting was uninspired, particularly from Pesci and Pacino who always seemed to be aware that they were being filmed, and DeNiro, who was wooden throughout. /Featured Stories Sidebar, Features, Netflix, Unpopular Opinion, Martin-Scorsese, Robert-De-Niro, The Irishman, The Quarantine Stream: ‘Thief’ is Michael Mann’s Stylish Feature Directorial Debut, Spoiler Discussion: WandaVision Episodes 1 & 2, ‘Locked Down’ Director Doug Liman on Shooting a Movie About the Pandemic During the Pandemic [Interview], ‘The Bourne Identity’ Director Doug Liman Still Doesn’t Know How to Feel About Bond Copying Bourne, ‘Cobra Kai’ Creators Reveal Which Characters Can Return to the Show and What to Expect from Season 4 [Interview], The First Two Episodes of ‘WandaVision’ Take Us Into the Weirdest Corner of the Marvel Cinematic Universe, Copyright © 2005-2019 /Film. The ending sucked...and I was just happy to get out of the theater. We can look on his mighty works, and rejoice. The Irishman represents a new kind of tech-enabled Kabuki theater. I shut it off. De Niro himself convinced us that he was the young Vito Corleone in The Godfather, Part II (this, despite taking the stage after Marlon Brando, which was no easy feat, back then). Worthless, senseless, violent, predictable, boring, walked out of the movie 45 mins into it. Robert DeNiro, who acts as a military veteran, who never served and as a bad ass that couldn't fight his way out of a wet paper bag. For your consideration: Goodfellas 3: The Golden Years.). There are no women, no blacks, no other ethnicities but Italians (even the “Irishman” is played by an Italian). Once great actors walk through their parts in a meandering tale with occasional gore and violence. Like Martin had a bet with Quentin Tarantino on making the longest, most boring movie and he won this year. TERRIBLY long.. and usually, tedious. A real, flesh-and-blood actor like him, instead of a video game approximation of De Niro in a World War II helmet, would have been such a simple, graceful solution. The greatest waste of movie budget in the history of movies. I would probably have enjoyed it more if it was my first gangster movie but this just about rolls through every cliche there is. The Irishman is certainly a work of cinema, however you want to define it. Poor character development and cohesive story. Why it is impossible to find new young actors, but not these old men? Please spare us from more of the tough guy schtick. I would probably have enjoyed it more if it was my first gangster movie but this just about rolls through every cliche there is. The movie seemed to have lost sight (or never had it) of what was the main story or character, and I felt myself struggling to figure that out every step of the way. In the end, The Irishman leaves off with many questions -- about legacy, regret, and more. The 16-minute, $70-million film was bankrolled by a Chinese casino. This film was so bad Hollywood didn’t even want it. My review: The Irishman is part of a dead genre that no one cares about anymore. Posted on Friday, November 29th, 2019 by Joshua Meyer, (Welcome to The Unpopular Opinion, a series where a writer goes to the defense of a much-maligned film or sets their sights on a movie seemingly beloved by all. Maybe I’m just a Luddite and need to get with the times and embrace the possibility of a digitally resurrected James Dean. Although performances were good I couldn't find the characters that convincing, This is the worst film of 2019. In the end, just a DEPRESSING excersize in Mafia bleakness; you don't care about ANY.
the irishman negative review 2021